Grades and test scores play an important role in college admissions, especially at selective institutions. They help admissions officers understand a student’s academic record, assess readiness for college-level coursework, and place performance in context. But numbers alone rarely determine the final decision.

At selective colleges, admissions officers are asking a broader set of questions. They want to understand what makes a student strong beyond classroom performance, how the student engages with learning and the world around them, and what they might contribute to the campus community.

‍

Intellectual Curiosity and Engagement

Admissions officers look for evidence that a student is genuinely interested in learning, not just earning high marks. This can appear in many forms, including the courses a student chooses, the way they pursue interests outside the classroom, and how they articulate their thinking in essays.

Intellectual curiosity may be demonstrated through formal research, advanced academic programs, sustained exploration through extracurricular activities, or independent projects. Admissions officers also rely heavily on the perspectives of people who know the student well, including teachers, school counselors, coaches, or other recommenders. Thoughtful reflection in essays and strong interview feedback can further reinforce a student’s intellectual engagement.

‍

Depth of Involvement Over Résumé Building

Beyond academics, admissions officers pay close attention to how students spend their time. College applications provide space for students to indicate how long they have participated in activities and how much time they commit each week.

Admissions officers are far less interested in long lists of disconnected activities than they are in depth, commitment, and growth. Sustained involvement in a few meaningful pursuits often signals maturity, responsibility, and genuine interest. Leadership is valued when it develops organically, but so are initiative, consistency, and impact within a chosen area.

‍

Character, Contribution, and Personal Qualities

Teacher recommendations and counselor letters are critical sources of insight into a student’s character. Admissions officers look for qualities such as integrity, resilience, collaboration, curiosity, and empathy.

These traits help admissions officers assess how a student is likely to function as a member of a campus community. Colleges are not only admitting students to attend classes but also to live, learn, and work alongside others in a shared environment.

‍

Personal Statement and Essays

Essays are one of the primary ways admissions officers gain insight into how a student thinks and reflects. Strong essays reveal aspects of a student that are not evident elsewhere in the application and help explain what motivates them or what experiences have shaped their perspective.

Admissions officers are skilled at distinguishing between writing that feels manufactured and writing that feels honest. Students who present themselves thoughtfully, with depth and consistency across the application, tend to leave the strongest impressions.

‍

Context and Personal Trajectory

Admissions officers also consider a student’s trajectory over time. They look at how a student has responded to challenges, taken advantage of opportunities, and grown academically and personally.

Context matters. The same achievement can carry different weight depending on a student’s environment, responsibilities, and access to resources. Understanding this context allows admissions officers to evaluate students more accurately and fairly.

‍

What This Means for Applicants

For students, this means that strong grades and test scores are necessary but rarely sufficient on their own at the most selective colleges. Admissions officers are looking for coherence across the application: academics that support interests, activities that reflect engagement, and writing that provides insight into who the student is.

Students who focus on depth, authenticity, and intentional choices are generally better positioned than those who optimize only for numerical outcomes.

‍

Our Strategic Advising Approach

Because our firm is led by former admissions officers, we approach holistic review from the same perspective used inside admissions offices. We help students understand how quantitative data and qualitative information are evaluated together, and how to present a clear, credible application that reflects who they are.

If you would like to learn more about our approach to advising, we invite you to get in touch.